×
×
Menu
Search

SILVA-TREVINO REMIX FROM THE BOARD OF IMMIGRATION APPEALS

HomeNews & EventsSILVA-TREVINO REMIX FROM THE BOARD OF IMMIGRATION APPEALS
READ FROM US

Immigration News & Events

Categories

Archives

SILVA-TREVINO REMIX FROM THE BOARD OF IMMIGRATION APPEALS

Share This Post: facebooktwitterLinkedIn

After the Attorney General’s 2015 decision (“Silva-Trevino 2”), that vacated the 2008 precedent decision in Matter of Silva-Trevino (“Silva-Trevino 1”), the Board of Immigration Appeals (“BIA”) just developed an important uniform standard that has wide applicability to immigration and criminal law. The case was remanded to the BIA to determine whether a particular criminal offense is a crime involving turpitude (“CIMT”). Such a determination is very important because if a person’s conviction is found to be CIMT, it is much more difficult, and sometimes impossible, for that person to become a permanent resident.

The “new” BIA framework adopts the well-established two part test reaffirmed by the Supreme Court in Moncrieffe and Descamps: (1) the categorical approach and (2) the modified categorical approach. When applying part 1, the “realistic probability” test is used to determine whether a crime is categorically a CIMT. The realistic probability test focuses on the minimum conduct that has a realistic probability of being prosecuted under the statute of conviction. If a person could be convicted of a CIMT under that minimum conduct, then that conviction is a CIMT.

If the CIMT analysis is clear after part 1, the inquiry ends there. If it is not clear after part 1, the analysis moves to part 2: the modified categorical approach. In part 2, the analysis focuses on the record of conviction. The Court or other decision-maker is not allowed to look outside of the record of conviction. When the record of conviction is conclusive, then the inquiry ends.

Under old BIA precedent, if the record is inconclusive, the burden would shift to the immigrant to prove that he or she was not convicted of a CIMT. If unable to do so, the Court would conclude that the conviction is a CIMT. However, there are a number of Circuit Court decisions that hold the opposite.

Under this new BIA decision, it is unclear what the outcome is in this scenario. That is because it appears that the BIA leaves it up to each Circuit Court to decide. Moreover, the BIA disposed of Silva-Trevino 2 under the categorical approach and stopped their inquiry at step one. Here in the Tenth Circuit, when the record of conviction is inconclusive, it appears that the burden shifts to the immigrant under Garcia v. Holder. However, this matter is still being litigated and it is likely to make its way to the Supreme Court at some point.

This new framework from the BIA solidifies the continuing trend of Circuit Court decisions and signals a clear return to the traditional two-step test. It remains to be seen how the various Circuit Courts will treat this recent BIA precedent decision. At least it is a step in the right direction in setting a clearer and more uniform analytical framework.

If you have any criminal convictions, please contact an attorney at the Joseph & Hall P.C. to do a complete analysis. This area of law is ever evolving and we will continue to monitor and report on the state of the law.

On December 23, 2016, the new fee schedule for U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) application and petition filing fees will go into effect.   Family-based petitions, employment-based petitions, and naturalization…

24Oct

I am completely stunned to be typing this, but Donald Trump has just been elected President of the United States.  Mr. Trump built much of his campaign around the promises…

09Nov

PERSONAL TOUCH AND SUPERIOR CUSTOMER SERVICE

Recognized Leaders In
Immigration Law

Joseph & Hall P.C. is a full-service immigration law firm. We pride ourselves on being nationwide experts in all areas of immigration law, including the practice areas listed below. Our attorneys frequently are asked to speak both locally and nationally on a wide variety of immigration topics. For an overview of each practice area, please click the links below. If you have any questions about how these practice areas may apply to your case, please do not hesitate to contact our firm.

OUR AWARDS & ACHIEVEMENTS

We Are Committed to Your Dreams.

Countless people dream of becoming a U.S. citizen. If your application was rejected by the USCIS, we are here to fight for your best interests.

Get in touch with us. Write us a message.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
×
×
Tap Here To Schedule An Appointment
It's Fast & Easy