FOIA Results: EOIR’s “Acceptance Guidelines for Notices to Appear”

HomeNews & EventsFOIA Results: EOIR’s “Acceptance Guidelines for Notices to Appear”

Immigration News & Events



FOIA Results: EOIR’s “Acceptance Guidelines for Notices to Appear”

Share This Post: facebooktwitterLinkedIn

On December 21, 2018, EOIR Director McHenry published PM 19-08, “Acceptance of Notices to Appear and Use of the Interactive Scheduling System.” That memo instructed immigration courts to “reject any NTA in which the time or date of the scheduled hearing is facially incorrect—e.g. a hearing scheduled on a weekend or holiday or at a time when the court is not open.”

Through the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), we requested supplemental guidance on when immigration courts were supposed to reject NTAs as facially incorrect.

In response, EOIR produced a chart of “Acceptance Guidelines for Notices to Appear.”  Most glaringly, the chart shows that immigration courts have been instructed to accept NTAs directing an initial appearance at a “TBD” time.  This is in spite of the Supreme Court’s holding that “…Congress fully intended to attach substantive significance to the requirement that noncitizens be given notice of at least the time and place of their removal proceedings” and that a “document that fails to include such information is not a “notice to appear” under the statute.  Pereira v. Sessions, 138 S. Ct. 2105, 2118 (2018).

The chart also indicates that if an NTA lists one court and the NTA is filed in another, the court NTA-receiving court should reject the NTA unless it is filed along with a DHS memo memorializing the change in location that has been served on the respondent.  It is unclear from the acceptance guidelines what that DHS “memo” would look like or what it would be required to contain.

We have requested further records related to PM 19-08 through FOIA and will update here if we receive results.

Click here to see EOIR’s “Acceptance Guidelines for Notices to Appear” chart.

President Trump has threatened to close the U.S.-Mexico border as early as this week if Mexico does not do more to control migrants coming across into the U.S. without authorization.…


Under federal law, it has long been illegal to possess, purchase, sell, or use marijuana. Over the past 6 years, 33 states and the District of Columbia have legalized medicinal…



Recognized Leaders In
Immigration Law

Joseph & Hall P.C. is a full-service immigration law firm. We pride ourselves on being nationwide experts in all areas of immigration law, including the practice areas listed below. Our attorneys frequently are asked to speak both locally and nationally on a wide variety of immigration topics. For an overview of each practice area, please click the links below. If you have any questions about how these practice areas may apply to your case, please do not hesitate to contact our firm.


We Are Committed to Your Dreams.

Countless people dream of becoming a U.S. citizen. If your application was rejected by the USCIS, we are here to fight for your best interests.

Get in touch with us. Write us a message.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Tap Here To Schedule An Appointment
It's Fast & Easy